
There used to be these old sayings in comics. "You can't change Batman's Identity." "Superman can't have a kid." "Jason Todd will always be dead." "Archie can't decide between Betty and Veronica." "Bucky Barnes will always be dead." and "Uncle Ben will always be dead."
My, how times have changed.
Jason Todd is alive. Bucky is alive. Archie is marrying Veronica. Superman has an adopted son. Batman is not Bruce Wayne (again). At least Uncle Ben is still dead.
Let's run down that list again. How many of these things have worked well. (From here on out I'm ignoring Archie). Jason Todd's return has been craptacular and pointless, Superman's adopted son was so rushed in storylines that I forget that Zod's son is Superman's adopted son, except when the kid calls Lois "mom." And the fact they had him for what seemed like 10 minutes and now he's 18 years old.
But Marvel and Ed Brubaker did it right with Bucky. It worked, it wasn't tacky, it's been going for well over 4 years and it's just been damn good.
So how about Batman. That's what I really want to talk about.
I was NEVER a fan of R.I.P. I thought it was contrived, pointless and poorly executed/written. I like Grant Morrison, I think he's written brilliant material, but I think his recent DC stuff has been lackluster. R.I.P. was also a mash-up of "Knightfall" with shades of "The Prodigal," 2 popular stories in the 90s, featuring Batman's back being broken and a new Batman taking over, and then Dick Grayson becoming Batman, respectively. Knightfall was okay. Looking back at it as I'm older, it was okay. It wasn't great, but it was okay. Personally, I thought Prodigal is one of the top Dick Grayson stories ever. He takes over as Batman, confronts Two-Face to settle his past mistakes as Robin, and then gives up the mantle of the Bat, knowing he couldn't be Batman.
That's one problem I have with this "Reborn" nonsense. Dick Grayson is NOT Batman. He should never be Batman and he has been poorly used as Nightwing over the past few years. Reading the current Batman titles, I have drawn one conclusion. "This is not Batman." It actually feels like a mockery of Batman. We have his wise-cracking adopted son taking over, not nearly as dark and not nearly as great, Bruce Wayne's apparent biological son who is kind of homicidal in a Stewie Griffin sort of way, and his other adopted son who is traveling the world in search of his identity because well, I don't think DC knows what to do with him. Then there's this new Batgirl, who will probably be Stephanie Brown, leaving Cassandra Cain probably still Batgirl but mucking up continuity even more... wow... what a mess.
The problem is that Bruce Wayne is forever Batman. I know, he'll probably be back next summer, but it doesn't sit well with me. With the exception of Green Lantern and a few other mini-series, DC is a mess. Final Crisis was pointless, it had very little effect on the universe, Batman has been horribly mistreated and while Blackest Night sounds awesome... it's just DC Zombies.

The Batman universe doesn't feel like Batman because Batman is indeed not there. There's always been the great debate over Bruce Wayne and Batman. Is Bruce Wayne Batman or is Batman Bruce Wayne? The answer, most of the time is that Batman IS Bruce Wayne... that Bruce Wayne is the shell. Thus, Dick Grayson, or anyone else for that matter, save for Terry McGinnis, does not work as Batman.
Bruce Wayne is not dead, we know this. Gotham City ridiculously fell into chaos because Batman was gone... so instead of martial law being imposed, or other heroes coming to help... which made no sense why they didn't, Gotham burned until Dick Grayson became "Batman." But the truth is it's all a sham. A poor publicity stunt by DC that tarnishes the legacy and will remind us all that Dick Grayson is not Batman. Batman is Bruce Wayne and without him, what should be the core of DC Comics, their most popular character, is falling apart.
The bottom line, and the lesson learned by "Knightfall," "Prodigal" and now "R.I.P./Battle for the Cowl/Reborn" is that Batman
IS Bruce Wayne. And until the real Batman returns to his rightful place, the Bat-books will not be the same and DC/WB's greatest character has been neutered in a terrible fashion.
Oh and one more thing... DiDio wrote in his DC Nation column about Dick Grayson becoming Batman, "Who said I wanted to kill Dick Grayson?" Oh, but Mr. D you have shown your hand. Dick Grayson's journey is complete, he is now Batman. Thus how do you effectively bring back Bruce Wayne and return his status? Ahh yes, you kill Dick Grayson. It is seemingly obvious.